Search cities, hotels, brands…

City dining guide

Best restaurants in Montiano

42 guide-listed restaurants — Michelin, Bib Gourmand, Black Pearl, Must-Eat List, World's 50 Best and more. Reference quality signals; never ranked by commission, no in-app checkout.

Michelin-starred 11

Caino

★★ Michelin€€€€Tuscan, Contemporary

Nestled in the heart of a charming Tuscan village, Caino is the gravitational centre of Maremma cuisine, with Valeria Piccini its finest interpreter: a skilful seeker of superior materials from a generous territory (which, along with a lovely vegetable garden, produces its own olive oil and some wines), later reimagining them without compromising an ounce of flavour—as in the delicious lamb ravioli or the pigeon stuffed with mashed potatoes and its entrails. For those craving a touch of the sea, there's an excellent risotto featuring cardoncelli mushrooms, lovage, and langoustines or amberjack

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.1/5 · 100 reviews

Caino in Montemerano offers contemporary Tuscan cuisine with an average TripAdvisor rating of 4.0/5 from 80 reviews. Positive feedback highlights food quality, atmosphere, and service, with guests praising Chef Valeria Piccini’s creativity and hospitality. However, negative reviews criticize declining food quality, poor value, and inconsistent service pacing. Some diners reported bland dishes, incorrect temperatures, and unpleasant odors in the dining area. While many describe the experience as magical and memorable, others express disappointment regarding recent changes and cost-effectiveness. The restaurant remains popular but shows mixed reception on current culinary execution.

Suitable for diners seeking classic Tuscan cuisine and unique ambiance, with prior verification of recent dish quality recommended.

Website

Campo del Drago

★★ Michelin€€€€Contemporary, Tuscan

A certain amount of patience is required to get to this restaurant accessed via a dusty yet attractive dirt track that wends its way through typical Tuscan landscapes. On arrival, you’ll find an enchanting village of medieval origin with a tower and an old, frescoed church, where the Rosewood Castiglion del Bosco (awarded 3 Michelin keys) offers excellent service, splendid guestrooms and one of the best restaurants in the region. Here, chef Matteo Temperini serves some of the most interesting and creative dishes in Tuscany, many of which are prepared using vegetables from the hotel’s own kitch

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.8/5 · 54 reviews

Located in Castiglione del Bosco, Campo del Drago offers contemporary Tuscan cuisine emphasizing high-quality ingredients, including self-produced organic vegetables and game salami. Reviews highlight exceptional food quality, professional service, and a relaxing atmosphere with soft lighting. The wine selection is praised, and the setting is ideal for special occasions. However, the remote location poses accessibility challenges, with some noting difficult access roads and high taxi costs. Occasional complaints regarding meal pacing and noise from children exist. Despite minor critiques on value, the restaurant maintains a strong 4.8/5 rating, delivering a refined and memorable dining experience for those willing to navigate its secluded setting.

Best suited for guests with transportation access seeking refined Tuscan cuisine in a serene setting.

Website

La Sala dei Grappoli

★ Michelin€€€€Modern Cuisine, Contemporary

A beautiful drive through typical picture-postcard Tuscan scenery of vineyards, cypress and olive trees takes you to the imposing medieval Castello Banfi, which stands proudly in front of this restaurant. La Sala dei Grappoli takes its name from the vines depicted in frescoes on the walls of its dining room, although in fine weather you’ll want to take advantage of the outdoor terrace where the beautiful views combine with impeccable service and superb cuisine to offer an unforgettable experience. Originally from Puglia, chef Domenico Francone includes Puglian specialities on the menu, such as

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.8/5 · 100 reviews

Located within Castello Banfi in Argiano, La Sala dei Grappoli offers modern contemporary cuisine. Based on 80 reviews averaging 4.8/5, guests frequently praise the food quality, attentive service, and extensive wine pairings. The castle setting provides a fairy-tale atmosphere with panoramic views of the Val d'Orcia, making it ideal for special occasions. While most experiences are exceptional, minor criticisms cite meal pacing and occasional value concerns. Overall, it is highly regarded as a premier dining destination in Tuscany.

Suitable for diners seeking a castle setting paired with modern fine dining for special occasions.

Website

Silene

★ Michelin€€€Tuscan, Modern Cuisine

In a tiny village at the foot of Mount Amiata, chef-patron Roberto Rossi captivates his guests within elegant and relaxed settings, offering decidedly Tuscan cuisine meticulously prepared, consolidating classic cooking techniques that reveal the fragrant flavour of prime materials. Moreover, when in season, the chef’s own garden plays a principal role in the menu (it’s a pleasure to visit and admire its “design”): excellent pigeon ravioli, alongside bread—which is among the chef’s passions—and a steadfast presence of fish dishes. The entire menu is seasoned with the chef's own Evo oil produced

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.5/5 · 100 reviews

Silene, located in Seggiano, specializes in modern Tuscan cuisine. Reviews highlight exceptional food quality, emphasizing fresh, local ingredients and creative presentations, including garden visits and chef-curated tasting menus. Service is generally professional and attentive, though some guests noted issues with meal pacing or consistency. The ambiance is described as elegant, warm, and comfortable. However, perceptions of value vary significantly. While many find the experience justified, others criticize the high prices relative to portion sizes or dish execution, leading to mixed feedback on overall worth despite the high culinary standards.

Suitable for diners seeking high-quality modern Tuscan cuisine who are less price-sensitive.

Website

La Trattoria Enrico Bartolini

★ Michelin€€€€Mediterranean Cuisine, Contemporary

After navigating a majestic, picture-postcard driveway lined with cypresses, maritime pines and vineyards, you arrive at the L’Andana resort: an oasis of charm where the restaurant is situated at the rear of the estate. The dining experience here is truly memorable thanks to two tasting menus — with dishes from both also available à la carte — designed to showcase the local terroir and contemporary cuisine.The longer one is a tribute to seafood, featuring fish dishes seductively interpreted using the grill, while the shorter menu is the result of the combination of the resident chef’s creative

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.2/5 · 100 reviews

La Trattoria Enrico Bartolini holds a 4.1/5 rating on TripAdvisor. Guests frequently praise the high-quality cuisine, highlighting fresh herbs, unique meat and fish tasting menus featuring dishes like veal sweetbreads, pecorino ravioli, and wagyu beef, alongside excellent wine pairings. Service is generally described as professional, attentive, and refined, creating an elegant atmosphere suitable for special occasions or honeymoons. However, negative reviews cite issues with rude staff, difficulty making reservations, and poor telephone communication. While the culinary experience is exceptional, some visitors note inconsistencies in service and question the value. Overall, it offers a sophisticated dining experience centered on gastronomy, though potential guests should be aware of occasional service variability.

Ideal for diners seeking refined cuisine and unique tasting experiences, with advance reservation confirmation recommended.

Website

Saporium

★ Michelin€€€€Tuscan, Italian Contemporary

Saporium is the new fine-dining restaurant at the superb Relais Borgo Santo Pietro, an old property where the internal decor demonstrates a rare elegance, especially in the evening when hundreds of candles provide soft lighting and a romantic ambience in the dining room. In fine weather, meals are served under an elegant 13C portico overlooking the garden, with the property’s 100ha grounds and the Valle Serena as a backdrop. Much of the produce used in the cuisine (designed by executive chef Ariel Hagan and transformed by resident chef Luca Ottogalli into modern, delicate dishes) comes from th

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.7/5 · 69 reviews

Located in Chiusdino, Saporium offers contemporary Tuscan Italian cuisine. Based on 69 reviews averaging 4.7/5, guests highly praise the food quality, service, and atmosphere. Many describe the experience as 'perfect' and 'unforgettable,' highlighting refined dishes, a varied wine list, and a magical, fairy-tale-like setting. While a few negative comments mention pacing issues and intrusive service, the overall consensus is that it provides a high-quality, romantic dining experience worth the trip.

Ideal for diners seeking refined Tuscan cuisine and a romantic atmosphere.

Website

La Parolina

★ Michelin€€€€Country cooking, Modern Cuisine

Just a few kilometres from Acquapendente, a must for those travelling the Via Francigena, in a residential location overlooking the bucolic valley below, Cesare and Romano's Iside offers local cuisine, rich in authentic flavours and local products, with a few technical touches, such as the iced chickpea hummus with a drizzle of local EVO oil, with incredible texture, or the lentil caviar to start. One of the highlights, when available, is the pigeon, delicate and tender, served with a succulent bruschetta with liver ragout and a dumpling in broth. The wine cellar offers good wine, some labels

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.6/5 · 100 reviews

Located in Trevinano, La Parolina serves modern country cuisine and holds a 4.7/5 rating on TripAdvisor. Most reviewers praise the high-quality, seasonal ingredients and creative dishes, such as chickpea humus, red turnip risotto, and innovative chicken preparations. The atmosphere is described as cozy and elegant, with friendly service and well-paced meals. However, some negative feedback highlights issues with flavor balance, such as overpowering fish fillings, or criticizes the small portions and perceived low value. It may not suit those preferring traditional pasta/pizza or strict budgets.

Suitable for diners seeking refined modern country cuisine, valuing ingredient innovation and atmosphere.

Website

Bracali

★ Michelin€€€€Italian Contemporary, Creative

In the center of the small hamlet of Ghirlanda, in the heart of the Colline Metallifere, a discreet entrance leads to the elegant restaurant run by the Bracali brothers. Chef Francesco skillfully navigates between two tasting menus (with dishes also available à la carte), offering modern creations of both meat and fish. Luca, on the other hand, manages the dining room and passionately oversees the wine cellar, which is extensive, well-structured, and divided into two distinct sections: Italy and the rest of the world. Special attention is given to vertical tastings, curated with genuine dedica

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.6/5 · 100 reviews

Located in a remote village near Massa Marittima, Bracali offers creative contemporary Italian cuisine. Reviews frequently praise the impeccable service, refined atmosphere, and high-quality food, describing it as a unique sensory experience. However, negative feedback highlights issues such as a shabby exterior, windowless interiors with tight spacing, poor soundproofing, and inconsistent meal pacing. Value perceptions are divided; some guests find the pricing excessive relative to the experience, citing strict booking policies, while others consider it justified. While the culinary execution and hospitality are highly rated by many, potential visitors should be aware of the cramped and noisy dining environment and varying opinions on cost-effectiveness.

Suitable for diners seeking exceptional creative cuisine and service, but be prepared for a cramped, noisy environment and high costs.

Website

Osmosi

★ Michelin€€€Contemporary, Creative

Set in open countryside, surrounded by orderly rows of vineyards, a historic villa houses Fattoria Svetoni, an estate devoted to hospitality, with elegant guest rooms, and to winemaking since 1865. It is here that the restaurant finds its home, arranged partly within the evocative ancient walls of the interior and partly in a strikingly modern glazed veranda that opens onto a pleasant and verdant prospect. The cooking of Mirko Marcelli expresses itself through a creativity that is measured and never excessive: the dishes possess a strong identity without ever imposing themselves, and the pairi

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.4/5 · 100 reviews

Located near Montepulciano, Osmosi offers contemporary creative cuisine. Reviews highlight the 'Substance' tasting menu for its intense flavors, artistic presentation, and standout dishes like mushrooms and seafood. The atmosphere is refined, with pleasant garden seating and professional sommelier service. While most praise the attentive staff, some note issues with meal pacing and inadequate accommodation for young children. Value is mixed, with some finding it expensive relative to portions. Occasional complaints cite undercooked fish and inconsistent flavor profiles. It is best suited for adults seeking a high-end culinary experience rather than families with toddlers.

Ideal for adults seeking refined creative cuisine; families with young children should verify service details beforehand.

Website

Il Pellicano

★ Michelin€€€€Creative, Italian Contemporary

Chef Michelino Gioia from Campania, now a Tuscan by adoption, is in charge of fine dining at the famous resort Il Pellicano, whose terrace overlooking the sea, enhanced by the scent of rosemary in the air, makes it one of the most romantic addresses in Italy. Michelino, thanks to a good technique, is highly skilled in creating different textures in the same dish while retaining the precise flavours of the excellent ingredients used, both land and sea (excellent, for example, the cooking of the pezzogna, which remains soft, accompanied by small quenelles of pappa al pomodoro in a creamy version

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.0/5 · 100 reviews

Il Pellicano offers stunning cliffside views and a relaxing atmosphere, particularly at sunset. Food quality is generally praised, with Chef Michele Gioia receiving acclaim for his culinary expertise and multi-course menus like the 'Sea Route'. However, service is inconsistent; while many find it warm and professional, others report significant delays, poor responsiveness, and booking difficulties. Value is mixed, with some feeling the cost does not justify the experience, especially given occasional noise from other diners. Despite these service flaws, the location and cuisine remain highlights. It suits travelers prioritizing scenic beauty and high-end dining, provided they manage expectations regarding service reliability.

Suitable for travelers prioritizing scenery and cuisine who can tolerate service inconsistencies.

Website

Contrada

★ Michelin€€€Modern Cuisine, Tuscan

In the charming setting of an old hamlet, chef Davide Canella, who has plenty of experience behind him, serves delicious, elegant cuisine presented on a tasting menu and an à la carte on which meat takes centre stage (although a few fish options also feature). Dishes include exquisite prawns and panzanella, and duck breast served with hosomaki. Manuela, the friendly, professional sommelier, oversees the front of house, offering excellent recommendations on the best wine pairings. In other words, a delightful all-round dining experience thanks to the competence and enthusiasm of all involved.

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.3/5 · 100 reviews

Contrada in Licola offers a renovated, comfortable setting with air conditioning and a garden featuring a lemon pergola. The menu focuses on pizza and modern Tuscan cuisine, offering a wide selection of seafood and land-based dishes, including paccheri with clams and porcini mushrooms. Notable strengths include high-quality gluten-free and vegan options. Service is generally praised for being friendly and unhurried, allowing guests to linger. However, value is a mixed point; some reviewers cite disproportionate prices, parking fee disputes, and inconsistent meal pacing. While most experiences are positive, isolated incidents of poorly cooked pizza and lack of apology have been noted. It suits diners seeking a relaxed atmosphere and specific dietary accommodations, though budget-conscious visitors should be aware of potential value inconsistencies.

Ideal for diners seeking a relaxed atmosphere, quality pizza, and gluten-free or vegan options, with prior confirmation of parking policies and value expectations recommended.

Website

Bib Gourmand 6

Taverna del Grappolo Blu

Bib GourmandTuscan

In the heart of Montalcino, this rustic and welcoming tavern offers authentic cuisine, built on tradition, simplicity and ingredients selected and prepared with passion. The most impressive dishes include homemade pici with meat sauce: an authentic, unpretentious version that captures the true flavour of the local cuisine. The wine list also deserves a mention, featuring a wealth of old vintages and characterised by a wide selection of local wines, to create the perfect pairing for every course.

TripAdvisor review sample · 3.1/5 · 80 reviews

Taverna del Grappolo Blu is a historic Tuscan restaurant in Montalcino, noted for its vaulted stone interiors and scenic outdoor patio overlooking the countryside. Reviews highlight a stark contrast between ambiance and service. While many appreciate the traditional decor and views, others report significant service failures, including rude staff, incorrect orders, slow pacing, and poor wine handling. Food quality is mixed; traditional dishes like Cinta Senese cold cuts, rabbit with polenta, and chestnut flour tagliatelle receive praise, but some find portions skimpy or flavors mediocre. Despite its long-standing presence and Michelin Guide inclusion, recent feedback suggests inconsistent execution, with complaints about value and professionalism outweighing the positive historical charm for several visitors.

Suitable for travelers prioritizing scenic views and historic ambiance over consistent service excellence.

Website

Osteria del Mare già il "Votapentole"

Bib Gourmand€€Seafood, Mediterranean Cuisine

In the city center, there's a small but lively restaurant with cheerful colors and a charming outdoor area on the pedestrian street. The atmosphere is always relaxed, even in summer when dining is only in the evening and tables are in high demand (reservations are essential). The menu is a journey through the sea: always featuring raw seafood, tuna amatriciana, cacciucco, and other classic dishes with imaginative touches.

TripAdvisor review sample · 3.8/5 · 80 reviews

Osteria del Mare offers Mediterranean seafood and Tuscan cuisine with an average TripAdvisor rating of 3.8/5. Food highlights include fresh wild octopus, oysters, and the signature cacciucco, praised for their quality and presentation. However, some guests found portions standard and quality unremarkable. Service is polarizing; while some appreciate the warmth, others report slow responses, arrogant attitudes, or discomfort due to drafts. The atmosphere is generally calm and authentic, though outdoor seating facilities are considered minimal. Value perceptions vary significantly, with conflicting reviews regarding whether the experience justifies the cost.

Suitable for diners seeking traditional Tuscan seafood who can tolerate inconsistent service.

Website

L'Oste Dispensa

Bib Gourmand€€Farm to table, Organic

Along one of the two strips of land that join the mainland to the Argentario is this contemporary osteria, minimal but comfortable and equipped with a pleasant veranda that opens in summer, always projecting toward a splendid view of the sea (don't miss the sunset if you can). The cuisine is based on local products, especially sustainably caught fish: not surprisingly, in keeping with this, the wine list features several organic labels. Highly recommended tasting menus that can range from 35 to 45 Euro. Better make reservations because they are extremely popular!

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.5/5 · 80 reviews

Located in Santa Liberata, L'Oste Dispensa emphasizes organic, farm-to-table dining. Food quality is generally praised for its freshness, particularly seafood, and unique preparation, though some find inconsistencies. Service receives mixed feedback; while many appreciate the friendly staff and helpful recommendations, others report rude behavior from specific employees and slow pacing. The atmosphere is relaxing with stunning views of the beach and the Tuscan archipelago sunset, but the venue can feel crowded. Perceived value varies significantly: some guests find the quality affordable, while others consider the menu unclear and the price-to-quality ratio mediocre.

Suitable for travelers seeking scenic sunset views and organic cuisine who can tolerate occasional service inconsistencies.

Website

Il Conte Matto

Bib Gourmand€€italian

The 14th-century home of the castle gamekeeper has been transformed into a showcase of regional products with a terrace overlooking the hills and, from the rooms, glimpses of the surrounding countryside. Chef Chiara's cooking is easy to read: Tuscan and local, with an emphasis on seasonal produce from the garden and nearby farmers. The triptych of hams is already a good reason to sit at the table, delicate and firm at the same time, with perfect seasoning! Among the starters, indulge in an artichoke flan; among the main courses, the classic Florentine steak or pigeon, served whole and flavoure

🕐 We-Mo 12:00-14:00, 19:00-21:00

Website

Il Sottomarino

Bib Gourmand€€Seafood, Mediterranean Cuisine

A lively restaurant on the seafront, featuring a pleasant terrace with panoramic views, which is highly sought after during the season – so it's best to book it as early as possible. For over twenty years, the solid family management has focused on excellent seafood cuisine, mostly classic, with some personal touches, especially in the desserts. Be sure to try the dark chocolate and crunchy cannoli, served vertically and filled with gianduja semifreddo, topped and plated with a cold Moscato d’Asti zabaglione.

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.4/5 · 80 reviews

Il Sottomarino in Follonica specializes in seafood and Mediterranean cuisine. Reviews highlight its elegant atmosphere, particularly the sea-view terrace, which is often cited as a prime location. Food quality receives mixed feedback; while many praise the refined preparation of dishes like mixed grills and taglierini, others criticize the portion sizes and presentation of grilled items. Service is generally appreciated for its attentiveness, including handling allergies, though some guests report booking difficulties or lackluster interaction. Value perceptions vary significantly, with some finding the experience justified and others feeling the cost outweighs the quality. It remains a notable dining spot where ambiance excels, but culinary consistency and service reliability can fluctuate.

Suitable for diners prioritizing scenic ambiance and atmosphere over consistent culinary perfection.

Website

Osteria La Solita Zuppa

Bib GourmandTuscan, Traditional Cuisine

In the heart of the historic centre of Chiusi, the authentic spirit of a true Tuscan trattoria pervades the air, between evocative barrel-vaulted ceilings and a cool terrace that invites one to linger. Here a love of regional cooking finds expression in the revival of ancient recipes, presented with the generous richness of flavour that characterises the local tradition. Among the dishes recommended by our Inspector, the fragrant artichoke and mint soup and the refined rabbit with ginger, inspired by an ancient medieval preparation, stand out.

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.2/5 · 80 reviews

Located in Cuneo, Osteria La Solita Zuppa offers traditional Tuscan-style simple dining, focusing on daily changing healthy soups and a limited selection of side dishes. Most reviews praise the freshness of ingredients and authentic, home-like flavors within a cozy atmosphere. Service opinions are mixed; while many appreciate the owners' warmth and professionalism, others note the restricted menu and frequent sell-outs by evening. Some guests experienced rushed service or perceived the ambiance as merely functional rather than engaging. Overall, it is a practical spot for quick lunches or light dinners. Despite its small scale and occasional availability issues, the consistent food quality makes it a reliable choice for those seeking healthy, straightforward meals without pretension.

Ideal for diners seeking healthy, home-style simplicity; visit during off-peak hours to ensure full menu availability.

Website

Other guide picks 25

Canapone

€€Classic Cuisine, Seafood

In classic settings embellished with many plants and customised by the porphyry floor, while in warm weather we move to the outdoor area overlooking the splendid Piazza Dante, in any case they serve Maremma cuisine of excellent fragrance and based on impeccable raw material, both fish (our suggestion goes for the steamed catch of the day with vegetables and freshly made mayonnaise) and meat. Next door, Osteria Canapino offers a more streamlined and informal cuisine.

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.5/5 · 80 reviews

Located in Grosseto's central square, Canapone is a historic restaurant specializing in classic cuisine and seafood. Reviews highlight its warm, elegant atmosphere and professional, friendly service. Many guests praise the fresh ingredients and refined presentation. However, some critics find the value lacking, citing high prices relative to portion sizes and occasional mediocrity in dish execution. Additional concerns include low indoor temperatures and inconsistent meal pacing. While generally recommended for those seeking traditional flavors and a pleasant setting, visitors should book in advance and manage expectations regarding cost-effectiveness.

Ideal for travelers seeking traditional classic cuisine and an elegant dining environment in Grosseto; reservations are recommended.

Website

L'Uva e il Malto

€€italian

A talented couple run this modern, intimate restaurant with a wine-bar right in the town centre. Fish takes pride of place on the menu, with the catch of the day announced at your table, including delicious shellfish. The female owner oversees the extensive wine list, which features reasonably priced and mostly Tuscan labels.

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.5/5 · 80 reviews

L'Uva e il Malto in Grosseto holds a strong reputation with an average rating of 4.5/5. Diners frequently praise the high quality and freshness of ingredients, particularly seafood dishes such as squid and mussels, which are enhanced by local truffles and fine wines. The service is noted for being professional, welcoming, and helpful with recommendations. The atmosphere is described as cozy, serene, and intimate. However, some reviews highlight inconsistencies regarding value for money, with certain dishes perceived as average or overpriced. Additionally, pacing issues were mentioned, with long waits between courses. While many find it a standout choice for quality, others suggest managing expectations regarding speed and cost.

Suitable for diners seeking high-quality seafood and wine experiences who can tolerate slower pacing.

Agriturismo Il Cavallino

€€Country cooking, Tuscan

A property located in a very peaceful setting within an organic farm stay. The management is driven by great passion: he works in the kitchen, carrying forward the family business tradition; she manages the dining room with grace and attention. The recipes offered are tied to the territory, with dishes that are generous, flavorful, and colorful, showing particular attention to the lightness of the preparations. The quality of their organic extra virgin olive oil is particularly noteworthy.

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.9/5 · 74 reviews

Agriturismo Il Cavallino in Semproniano specializes in Tuscan country cuisine, holding a 4.9/5 average from 74 reviews. Positive feedback highlights high-quality ingredients, skilled preparation, and warm hospitality within a tranquil, elegant setting. Some negative reviews criticize the service for being too fast and impersonal, with concerns regarding value for money. While a minority found the decor overly austere or the pacing rushed, most diners appreciate the seasonal approach and traditional flavors. The establishment functions as both accommodation and dining venue, generally praised for its authentic connection to the land and attentive staff.

Ideal for travelers seeking a peaceful rural atmosphere and authentic, ingredient-focused traditional cuisine.

Website

I Due Cippi dal 1976

€€€Meats and Grills, Classic Cuisine

Upon entering, guests are welcomed by an evocative crackling fireplace, beside which aged meat is cooked to perfection. The varieties offered come from the world’s finest regions and sustainable farms, including prized wagyu. Chianina naturally takes center stage, but the menu extends to game as well, offering a wide range of authentic flavors. The elegant dining rooms, which have gained charm and refinement over the years, are the result of management that began in the 1970s and is now more vibrant than ever. A warm atmosphere, attentive service, and a selection of prestigious labels complete

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.1/5 · 80 reviews

Located in Saturnia, I Due Cippi dal 1976 is renowned for high-quality meats and classic cuisine. Reviews frequently praise the exceptional cooking standards, extensive meat selection, and impressive wine list, noting an elegant atmosphere and generally attentive service. However, negative feedback highlights issues such as inconsistent service professionalism, difficulties with reservations, and billing problems. While some consider it a world-class steakhouse, others find the prices high relative to the experience, with some noting a shift towards a more formal, less cozy vibe over the decades. It offers a strong culinary focus but requires patience regarding service consistency.

Suitable for diners seeking premium meat quality and classic Italian dining who can tolerate occasional service inconsistencies.

Website

Boccon DiVino

€€Tuscan, Modern Cuisine

At the edge of the town, a skilfully restored farmhouse welcomes guests into an atmosphere of refined simplicity: from the carefully appointed rustic dining room to the bright glazed terrace, pleasant even in winter.The kitchen celebrates the flavours of the territory, reinterpreted in a measured contemporary key, without forgoing certain great classics such as peposo and onion soup.The wine list favours the local reds, with particular attention to Brunello and to labels of mature vintages. In the dining room, a warm welcome and assured knowledge of wine contribute to making the experience all

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.4/5 · 80 reviews

Boccon DiVino in Montalcino offers modern Tuscan cuisine with panoramic views. Guests frequently praise the blend of traditional flavors with refined techniques, highlighting dishes like pumpkin soup, tomato gruel, and beef cheeks. The atmosphere is described as comfortable, with knowledgeable and attentive staff. However, some reviews note issues with meal pacing, such as long waits for orders and cold food. Negative feedback also mentions limited à la carte options, unclear menu explanations, and high cancellation fees. While the setting and core culinary execution are strong, service consistency varies. It suits travelers seeking scenic dining and authentic regional flavors, provided they manage expectations regarding timing and flexibility.

Ideal for diners seeking stunning views and traditional Tuscan flavors, with advice to confirm menu details and allow ample time for the meal.

Website

La Filanda

€€Tuscan, Modern Cuisine

Situated in the heart of the historic centre, this restaurant occupies an old spinning mill ("filanda") that has been completely restored without losing any of its original charm. Here, self-taught chef Barbara serves traditional dishes reinterpreted with real flair, such as the involtino di ciaffagnone filled with Maremma beef on a bed of melted pecorino cheese and crispy leek. The chef’s husband oversees the wine list, which includes a selection of Tuscan labels.

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.8/5 · 80 reviews

La Filanda in Manciano offers modern Tuscan cuisine with an average rating of 4.8/5 from 80 reviews. Guests frequently praise the high food quality, welcoming atmosphere, and professional service, particularly highlighting the engaging cooking classes with Chef Barbara Cannarsa. The venue, housed in a tastefully restored historic building, provides a refined setting ideal for romantic occasions. However, some negative feedback points to inconsistent service, including delayed courses, missing cutlery, and staff unfamiliarity with menu items. A few reviewers also noted small portions relative to cost. While the culinary experience is generally exceptional, occasional lapses in service efficiency and value perception should be considered.

Ideal for travelers seeking high-quality Tuscan cuisine, romantic ambiance, and cooking classes, though those sensitive to service consistency and portion size may want to manage expectations.

Website

Taverna da Ciacco

€€Tuscan, Traditional Cuisine

In the heart of the pedestrian historic center, this venue offers a warm welcome in a rustic dining room or at a few tables overlooking the paseo. Family-run, it serves authentic Tuscan flavors prepared traditionally. The handmade pici with cherry tomatoes, olives, and slightly spicy anchovies are an unmissable summer delight!

TripAdvisor review sample · 3.4/5 · 80 reviews

Taverna da Ciacco specializes in traditional Tuscan seafood, receiving polarized reviews. Positive feedback highlights fresh ingredients, particularly raw fish and mussels, alongside a welcoming atmosphere created by the owner, Chicco. Conversely, negative reviews cite inconsistent food quality, including issues with bone-in raw fish, cold temperatures, and poor texture. Service is divisive, ranging from attentive to perceived rudeness or unpredictability. Meal pacing can be erratic, and while the decor is characteristic, it does not fully offset the variability in cuisine and hospitality.

Suitable for diners seeking authentic home-style seafood who can tolerate service variability.

Trattoria Toscana al Vecchio Forno

€€Tuscan, Traditional Cuisine

In the heart of San Quirico d’Orcia, an intimate trattoria welcomes guests with two small rooms on the upper floor, a main dining room animated by the warmth of the fireplace and an elegant pergola garden that opens during the warmer months. The setting, rustic and genuine, provides the backdrop for cooking deeply rooted in tradition: meats and game, the aromas of truffle and hand-rolled pasta tell the story of the territory with authenticity. Completing the experience, a well-constructed wine list, rich in local labels, accompanies the gastronomic journey with understated expertise.

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.6/5 · 80 reviews

Trattoria Toscana al Vecchio Forno in San Quirico d'Orcia is known for traditional Tuscan cuisine and a pleasant garden setting. Most reviews praise the authentic food, friendly staff, and comfortable atmosphere, highlighting the garden as a key feature. However, some customers report slow meal pacing and inconsistent attentiveness. Negative feedback focuses on value, with diners finding prices high relative to quality. Specific complaints include bland vegetable cakes and lumpy cheese sauces. While overall ratings are strong, experiences vary based on service timing and specific dish preparation.

Suitable for travelers seeking traditional flavors and garden dining; manage expectations regarding price and service speed.

Website

Il Tufo Allegro

€€Tuscan, Regional Cuisine

In the heart of one of Tuscany’s most spectacular villages, steps from the Synagogue, sits a small restaurant carved into the tufa stone, with intimate dining rooms and a truly well‑stocked wine cellar. The cuisine is authentically Tuscan: tradition and quality meet in every dish, thanks to local ingredients such as extra‑virgin olive oil, meats, cured meats, and cheeses carefully selected from the surrounding area. An experience to savor, with genuine flavors and a timeless atmosphere.

TripAdvisor review sample · 3.8/5 · 80 reviews

Il Tufo Allegro in Pitigliano serves Tuscan regional cuisine, holding an average TripAdvisor rating of 3.8/5 from 80 reviews. Food quality receives mixed feedback; while many praise dishes like ricotta and spinach ravioli, butter gnudi, and wild boar, others criticize portion sizes and consistency. Service is frequently described as friendly and attentive, yet significant complaints cite excessive wait times and poor pacing, with some diners waiting hours for orders. The atmosphere is highlighted as romantic and charming, featuring elegant rooms excavated in tufa stone within a quiet side alley. Although the setting is beautiful, operational inefficiencies regarding service speed and organization detract from the experience for some visitors.

Suitable for diners seeking a unique tufa-stone ambiance and authentic Tuscan flavors, provided they are prepared for potential service delays.

Website

Daniela

€€Tuscan

Having arrived in the picturesque village of San Casciano, we recommend a charming walk through the cobbled streets to admire its perfect preservation. Next, in the main square, take a seat at Daniela's. The Tuscan menu offers homemade pastas and a small wine list that celebrates Tuscany, with an international twist such as Greystone's 2016 Thomas Brother Pinot Noir. Among the delicacies on offer, you will find pici all'aglione, pappardelle al cinghiale, porchettato rabbit and grilled veal tenderloin: in short, a choice for all tastes! The cosy rooms are carved out of old stone spaces, and the

TripAdvisor review sample · 3.6/5 · 80 reviews

Daniela, located in San Casciano dei Bagni, offers Tuscan cuisine in a setting characterized by stone walls and vaults. Reviews on food quality are polarized; while some praise the ribollita, rabbit, and pigeon-filled pasta, others criticize undercooked spaghetti and bland beef with small portions. Service experiences vary significantly, ranging from attentive and warm to cold and unwelcoming. The most common complaint concerns value for money, with many finding the prices high relative to the quality, although some diners still consider it fair. The atmosphere is generally appreciated for its rustic charm.

Suitable for diners seeking traditional Tuscan ambiance who are less sensitive to price, with prior verification of dish quality recommended.

Website

Lupaia

€€€Country cooking, Farm to table

An enchanting setting, a Tuscan hamlet nestled among the hills between Montepulciano and Montefollonico, from which breathtaking sunsets may be enjoyed; tables in the open air during the warmer months, while in the cooler season the dining room looks out onto a splendid open kitchen. The gastronomic offering is determined daily by the chef, whose tasting menu draws above all upon the produce of the estate. Booking is essential for those not staying in the hamlet, and the journey to reach it is thoroughly bucolic.

Website

Le Logge del Vignola

€€italian

This small establishment is a good spot in the old town centre. Its tables are a bit cramped but they have smart table settings and well - prepared, regional ingredients are served.

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.5/5 · 80 reviews

Located in central Montepulciano, Le Logge del Vignola is a long-standing Michelin restaurant. Most reviews praise its elegant, clean ambiance with soft music and professional service, particularly highlighting staff members Virginia and Massimo. The cuisine blends traditional Tuscan flavors with innovation, featuring dishes like blue egg and fried lamb ribs, noted for fresh ingredients and varied menus. However, some guests question the value, citing over 100 euros per person for tasting menus as expensive. Negative feedback mentions slow pacing, stale bread, and indifferent service responses. With limited seating (around 15), it offers high-quality dining but requires attention to service consistency and cost-effectiveness.

Suitable for diners seeking refined Tuscan cuisine and elegant ambiance; reservations recommended.

Website

Indigeno

€€Traditional Cuisine, Tuscan

Boasting an unusually beautiful setting within the Salcheto Organic Winery amid the rolling hills around Montepulciano, this 13C farmhouse has been converted into a wine estate that also includes a restaurant. Simple, home-style cooking with a focus on local traditions takes pride of place here, with dishes made from ingredients either produced on the estate itself or sourced from small-scale local producers. Guests sit at large shared tables made from Amiata oak, or outdoors in summer, where they can enjoy home-made bread and numerous other specialities, including bread gnocchetti with creame

Website

Da Nilo

€€Tuscan

In the heart of Cetona's square, a well-tended outdoor area among hedges welcomes guests with warmth and smiles. The cuisine is authentically Tuscan and well-crafted. Don’t miss the selection of local cured meats and the classic pici all’aglione, a true must-try!

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.6/5 · 80 reviews

Da Nilo, located in Cetona's main square, serves Tuscan cuisine. Reviews highlight high food quality, with standout dishes like roast rabbit, wild boar with polenta, and handmade pasta praised for fresh flavors. Service is generally friendly and efficient, with staff offering expert recommendations. The atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, featuring a pleasant terrace ideal for summer dining. While a few guests noted issues with overly salty dishes or inconsistent execution, the overall experience remains positive. The restaurant offers a homely vibe and solid value, making it a reliable choice for travelers seeking authentic local dining.

Suitable for travelers seeking authentic Tuscan flavors and a warm, family-style dining experience.

Website

I Salotti

€€€€Creative

In summer, the outdoor spaces at this restaurant, such as the garden gazebo, are the perfect setting for a candlelit dinner in total harmony with nature, while in winter, the elegant dining room with just a few tables (book well in advance) really comes into its own. Creative cuisine prepared using produce from the restaurant’s own farm, plus a long-established wine cellar that has been extended over the years so that it now boasts over two thousand different labels from the region and elsewhere in Italy, many of them of the highest quality.

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.4/5 · 80 reviews

Located within a castle in Chiusi, I Salotti offers a distinctive setting. Reviews frequently praise the creative cuisine by Chefs Katia and Maccari, highlighting high-quality local ingredients and engaging dish narratives delivered by knowledgeable staff. The atmosphere is generally described as welcoming yet formal. However, some guests report inconsistent food quality, with specific complaints about main courses while desserts were acceptable. Negative feedback also cites issues with reservation communication, limited outdoor seating, and mosquito problems. While many describe it as an emotional and excellent experience, others found the formality excessive or the value lacking compared to expectations.

Suitable for diners seeking a unique castle setting and creative cuisine, provided they have high expectations for service consistency and food quality.

Website

Oasi

€€€Seafood, Mediterranean Cuisine

Over the years, the beach establishment has gradually developed: the beach and bar remain, but today's pride is the restaurant. The husband and wife divide their duties between the kitchen and dining area (including wine). They've built a good reputation thanks to classic seafood cuisine, highlighted by the chef's personal creative touches. A passionate and imaginative self-taught chef, his steamed oyster seasoned with lemon zest on tomato water is a particularly tasty shot that represents their style.

TripAdvisor review sample · 3.5/5 · 80 reviews

Located on the Follonica waterfront, Oasi offers Mediterranean seafood cuisine. Many reviews praise the freshness of ingredients and refined presentation, highlighting dishes like amberjack tartare, paccheri with hedgehogs, and shellfish bisque. Chef Mirko Martinelli often guides the dining experience. The atmosphere is pleasant with sea views, and service is generally friendly. However, negative feedback cites slow pacing, inconsistent dish temperatures (e.g., charred outside, raw inside), and occasional issues like sand in pasta. While food quality is widely appreciated, value for money is debated; some find it justified, while others consider prices too high relative to portion sizes. Overall, experiences vary significantly.

Suitable for diners seeking high-quality seafood and sea views, but manage expectations regarding service pace and value.

Website

Radici

€€€Creative, Modern Cuisine

Served in an elegant dining room or on the delightful outdoor terrace in fine weather, the highly creative cuisine at this restaurant has its roots in regional traditions and excellent local producers, while its stunning location within the luxurious Hotel Borgo La Chiaracia among the region’s verdant winding valleys makes it difficult to leave. With a choice of à la carte and tasting menus, our inspectors were particularly impressed by the Origini 20menu, on which all the ingredients are sourced within a 20km radius of the restaurant.

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.9/5 · 80 reviews

Located in Castel Giorgio, Radici offers creative modern cuisine with an exceptional 4.9/5 rating. Guests consistently praise the high-quality raw materials, inventive dishes, and professional yet friendly service. The 'chef's choice' menu and extensive wine list are highlights, set within an elegant resort environment. While most experiences are outstanding, some reviewers note that extreme flavors can be hard to appreciate, and recent changes in chef or limited menu variety have led to occasional dissatisfaction. Overall, it remains a top-tier destination for adventurous diners seeking culinary excellence.

Ideal for adventurous diners seeking innovative cuisine and unique flavor profiles.

Website

Gallo Nero

€€€Regional Cuisine, Contemporary

Just a short distance from Campo, at the boundary of the Leocorno contrada, the restaurant settles at the foot of a medieval tower: a thirteenth-century structure that once served as an armoury and which today, following a careful restoration, receives its guests in surroundings enriched by design furnishings from the 1950s and 1970s. It is here that the gastronomic offering of the Gallo Nero takes shape, with a cuisine that celebrates the Sienese tradition through meat dishes firmly rooted in the territory, set alongside vegetable creations and forays towards the sea. The cellar, nestled with

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.6/5 · 80 reviews

Located in a 12th-century armory in Siena, Gallo Nero offers a contemporary regional cuisine set in a historic, atmospheric venue. Reviews highlight exceptional food quality, with dishes praised for their intricate presentation, high-quality ingredients, and flexible gluten-free options. The service is generally commended for its attentiveness and the proprietor's hospitality. However, experiences vary significantly. Negative feedback points to inconsistent portion sizes, slow meal pacing, and long wait times. Some diners found certain dishes conceptually ambiguous or underwhelming compared to traditional expectations. While many describe it as an extraordinary culinary event, others report disappointment regarding value and execution.

Suitable for diners seeking a unique historical ambiance and innovative cuisine who can tolerate potential service inconsistencies.

Website

Osteria le Logge

€€Contemporary

Having retained its old shop counter and glass - fronted display cabinets, this former grocer’s shop is perfect for anyone in search of old - world charm. However, the cuisine is the real draw with its focus on quality of the highest level. Wine buffs can ask to visit the wine cellar nearby, housed in a tunnel of Etruscan origin. Simpler dining room on the first floor.

TripAdvisor review sample · 3.6/5 · 80 reviews

Located in Siena, Osteria le Logge occupies a former apothecary, offering a unique and intimate atmosphere. Based on 80 reviews averaging 3.6/5, positive feedback highlights food quality, professional service, and an extensive wine list, with some comparing the experience to Michelin standards. Conversely, criticisms focus on bland flavors, small portions, and poor value for money. A minority of reviewers reported issues with discriminatory service and inadequate seating arrangements. While the ambiance and staff professionalism are generally praised, the culinary execution and pricing remain divisive. Advance booking is recommended.

Suitable for diners prioritizing ambiance and service, though those seeking high value or consistent flavor intensity should proceed with caution.

Website

Campo Cedro

€€Italian Contemporary, Mediterranean Cuisine

Situated just a stone’s throw from the centre yet away from the tourist crowds, this restaurant is well worth the effort needed to find it! Here, Japanese chef Sugihara, who has more than 20 years’ experience working in Italy, creates modern and skilfully prepared Italian meat and fish dishes which are fresh and elaborate. You’ll nearly always find seafood risotto on the menu, which is made with fish, mussels and finely chopped shrimps all cooked together with rice and then sprinkled with crumbled seaweed and dotted with tomato paste. Excellent value for money!

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.9/5 · 80 reviews

Located in Siena, Campo Cedro serves contemporary Italian and Mediterranean cuisine, holding an average TripAdvisor rating of 4.9/5 based on 80 reviews. Guests consistently praise the high quality of fresh ingredients, creative presentation, and exceptional flavors, noting the chef's precision. Service is generally described as friendly, professional, and attentive, with staff offering helpful recommendations. The atmosphere is elegant and welcoming, making it suitable for special occasions like anniversaries. While a minority of reviews mention issues with meal pacing or value, the overwhelming consensus highlights the restaurant's excellence and strong recommendation.

Ideal for diners seeking high-quality contemporary Italian cuisine in an elegant setting.

Website

Particolare di Siena

€€€Modern Cuisine, Contemporary

A fine-dining restaurant which changed tack in 2020, reducing its number of tables to just ten and embracing a sustainable approach to its cuisine. It now prioritises local suppliers and certified organic and environmentally friendly ingredients, while the restaurant’s own kitchen garden, featuring produce grown in line with biodynamic techniques, provides some of the best seasonal ingredients used in the dishes here.

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.1/5 · 80 reviews

Particolare di Siena offers modern contemporary cuisine in Siena, holding a 4.1/5 average from 80 reviews. Positive feedback highlights fresh ingredients, beautifully presented fish dishes, and the owner Mattia’s friendly, knowledgeable service. The atmosphere is described as sophisticated yet welcoming. Conversely, criticisms mention small portion sizes, overly formal service, and inconsistent experiences following management changes. Severe negative reviews cite booking fraud and unresponsive phones. While food quality and ambiance are generally praised, value and service reliability remain points of contention.

Suitable for diners seeking refined modern cuisine and a warm atmosphere, though verify bookings and portion expectations.

Website

Osteria Il Granaio

€€Classic Cuisine

Although it calls itself an osteria, Il Granaio is really a restaurant. It has elegant brick - arched dining rooms occupying a 17C palazzo in the historic centre of Rapolano. On the menu you will find Tuscan specialities such as pici pasta cooked with various sauces, peppery Tuscan beef stew and a selection of fish dishes.

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.8/5 · 80 reviews

Located in Rapolano Terme, Osteria Il Granaio is renowned for its classic cuisine and high customer satisfaction, averaging 4.8/5. Reviews frequently praise the exceptional food quality, highlighting unique dishes featuring local ingredients such as Chianina beef ragout and peposo. The service is consistently described as warm, professional, and attentive, contributing to a convivial atmosphere. The ambiance blends elegance with rustic comfort, offering a serene dining experience. While some guests note concerns regarding portion sizes and value for money, the majority emphasize the memorable flavors and refined yet approachable setting. Occasional criticisms mention meal pacing and isolated hygiene issues, but these are outweighed by widespread acclaim for the culinary expertise and hospitality.

Ideal for travelers seeking high-quality classic Italian cuisine and a warm, refined dining atmosphere.

Website

Pepe Nero

€€Seafood, Modern Cuisine

Overlooking the western shore of Lake Bolsena, Pepe Nero is an intimate restaurant that wins one over through its modern furnishings and a pleasing maritime character. The service, gentle and professional, discreetly accompanies a predominantly seafood gastronomic journey, conceived for an immersive and unhurried experience of flavour. Guests may opt for themed menus or entrust themselves to the carte, choosing at least two dishes. The wine list ranges across regional and national labels, while in the warmer months a small terrace at the water’s edge affords the pleasure of dining with a direc

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.1/5 · 59 reviews

Pepe Nero, situated on Lake Bolsena, offers modern seafood cuisine with elegant lake views. Reviews frequently praise the freshness of ingredients, technical cooking skills, and artistic presentation, creating a relaxed and sophisticated atmosphere. Service is generally described as professional and attentive. However, negative feedback highlights inconsistencies in meal pacing, controversial flavor combinations, and perceived poor value, with some diners reporting insufficient portions or unsatisfactory tastes. While the location and culinary creativity are standout features, the overall experience varies based on specific orders and service execution.

Suitable for diners seeking lake views and modern seafood creativity; verify menu options in advance to avoid portion or taste disputes.

Website

Walter Redaelli

€€Modern Cuisine, Traditional Cuisine

In this old 18C farmhouse with exposed brickwork, roof beams and an impressive fireplace, enjoy delicious Tuscan cuisine prepared from local ingredients, with a particular focus on meat. Specialities on the menu include pappa al pomodoro, home-made pici pasta, and sliced veal. Comfortable chairs add to the cosy and enjoyable dining experience.

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.5/5 · 80 reviews

Located in Bettolle, Walter Redaelli offers modern and traditional cuisine praised for high-quality ingredients and refined, digestible dishes like liver crostini and tenderloin. The atmosphere is elegant and welcoming, featuring a terrace, with generally professional service. However, some reviews note inconsistent meal pacing, service errors, and concerns over value for money, particularly regarding high bills for modest portions. While many highlight the chef's skill and warm hospitality, others experienced average food quality or poor service. It remains a notable destination for those seeking sophisticated Tuscan-Umbrian dining, though guests should manage expectations regarding pricing and service consistency.

Suitable for diners seeking refined traditional-modern fusion cuisine and an elegant setting, with advance booking recommended.

Website

Tosca

€€€€Mediterranean Cuisine, Classic Cuisine

Set within the ancient Castello di Casole, Tosca establishes itself as a venue of great character, where warm and refined atmospheres take shape among exposed stone, sumptuous fabrics, and elegantly crafted furnishings. In the kitchen, the tasting menus reinterpret the Mediterranean tradition with a contemporary sensitivity, celebrating the seasonality and quality of the ingredients. Complementing this vision is the Territori project, which expresses a deep connection with the property’s agricultural surroundings: the Orti del Castello kitchen gardens, expanded with fruit trees and plants, nou