Search cities, hotels, brands…

City dining guide

Best restaurants in Monte Argentario

2 guide-listed restaurants — Michelin, Bib Gourmand, Black Pearl, Must-Eat List, World's 50 Best and more. Reference quality signals; never ranked by commission, no in-app checkout.

Michelin-starred 1

Il Pellicano

★ Michelin€€€€Creative, Italian Contemporary

Chef Michelino Gioia from Campania, now a Tuscan by adoption, is in charge of fine dining at the famous resort Il Pellicano, whose terrace overlooking the sea, enhanced by the scent of rosemary in the air, makes it one of the most romantic addresses in Italy. Michelino, thanks to a good technique, is highly skilled in creating different textures in the same dish while retaining the precise flavours of the excellent ingredients used, both land and sea (excellent, for example, the cooking of the pezzogna, which remains soft, accompanied by small quenelles of pappa al pomodoro in a creamy version

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.0/5 · 100 reviews

Il Pellicano offers stunning cliffside views and a relaxing atmosphere, particularly at sunset. Food quality is generally praised, with Chef Michele Gioia receiving acclaim for his culinary expertise and multi-course menus like the 'Sea Route'. However, service is inconsistent; while many find it warm and professional, others report significant delays, poor responsiveness, and booking difficulties. Value is mixed, with some feeling the cost does not justify the experience, especially given occasional noise from other diners. Despite these service flaws, the location and cuisine remain highlights. It suits travelers prioritizing scenic beauty and high-end dining, provided they manage expectations regarding service reliability.

Suitable for travelers prioritizing scenery and cuisine who can tolerate service inconsistencies.

Website

Bib Gourmand 1

L'Oste Dispensa

Bib Gourmand€€Farm to table, Organic

Along one of the two strips of land that join the mainland to the Argentario is this contemporary osteria, minimal but comfortable and equipped with a pleasant veranda that opens in summer, always projecting toward a splendid view of the sea (don't miss the sunset if you can). The cuisine is based on local products, especially sustainably caught fish: not surprisingly, in keeping with this, the wine list features several organic labels. Highly recommended tasting menus that can range from 35 to 45 Euro. Better make reservations because they are extremely popular!

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.5/5 · 80 reviews

Located in Santa Liberata, L'Oste Dispensa emphasizes organic, farm-to-table dining. Food quality is generally praised for its freshness, particularly seafood, and unique preparation, though some find inconsistencies. Service receives mixed feedback; while many appreciate the friendly staff and helpful recommendations, others report rude behavior from specific employees and slow pacing. The atmosphere is relaxing with stunning views of the beach and the Tuscan archipelago sunset, but the venue can feel crowded. Perceived value varies significantly: some guests find the quality affordable, while others consider the menu unclear and the price-to-quality ratio mediocre.

Suitable for travelers seeking scenic sunset views and organic cuisine who can tolerate occasional service inconsistencies.

Website