$$$French
Situated just past the entrance to the Beaver Creek Resort, in a picturesque turn-of-the-century ranch house (built by homesteaders in 1898), this local staple is the residence of longtime Chef Daniel Joly and his family, which helps to explain its homey, inviting charm. Chef Joly brings his European training to bear on comforting classics like lobster bisque, as well as indulgences like seared foie gras with caramelized peaches and Speculoos crumble; an order of frites with Dijon-spiked mayonnaise, a nod to his Belgian roots, is also a must. Portions are generous, but saving room for dessert
TripAdvisor review sample · 3.7/5 · 80 reviews
Mirabelle, located on the Stony Brook harbor, offers a charming historic atmosphere suitable for special occasions. Food quality receives mixed reviews; while dishes like Scottish salmon, boneless short ribs, and octopus are praised, others report slow pacing, overcooked halibut, or inconsistent temperatures. Service is generally noted as excellent by some, particularly the manager, though complaints exist regarding delays and menu inaccuracies. The ambiance is widely appreciated for its warmth and suitability for photos. However, value is frequently questioned, with some finding prices high relative to portion sizes. Negative experiences were notably reported during holiday buffets due to management issues.
Suitable for diners seeking a romantic historic ambiance, but avoid holiday peaks and verify dishes carefully.
$$$$Contemporary
You might think the name lays things on a bit thick, but the setting is as grand and as comfortable as could be hoped for, and the warm, attentive service is sure to make you feel like royalty. Looking beyond the glamorous environs, you'll find a thoughtful menu overseen by longtime chef Brian Ackerman, which straddles the line between creative and classic, seen in a pomegranate-marinated rack of Colorado lamb. Dover sole, pan-seared before being adroitly filleted tableside and served with brown butter beurre blanc, is a menu staple for good reason. End with an airy soufflé, or opt for somethi
TripAdvisor review sample · 4.2/5 · 80 reviews
Located at the Chateau, Splendido offers a sophisticated atmosphere with stunning mountain views. Food quality is generally praised, with scallop crudo, beef tartare, and duck receiving high marks, though some note recent declines in freshness and menu similarity. Service is mixed; while many appreciate attentive staff, complaints cite slow pacing and unhelpful management responses. Value is contentious, with critics finding prices high relative to portions and experience. It suits travelers seeking scenic, upscale dining, but those sensitive to wait times or cost may find it less appealing.
Recommended for diners prioritizing scenic views and refined cuisine, with expectations set regarding service pace.
$$$$american
Wine bar
TripAdvisor review sample · 3.4/5 · 80 reviews
Located in the heart of Vail Village, Sweet Basil offers an elegant atmosphere and generally praised service, with staff often providing expert wine pairings. Food quality receives mixed reviews; while some diners appreciate the refined presentation, appetizers like whipped feta, and seafood, many criticize dishes for being overly heavy, salty, or poorly executed, including reports of tough steaks. Although the ambiance is comfortable, some experiences are marred by slow pacing and perceived poor value. Overall, it suits those seeking a sophisticated setting and good wine selection, but travelers with high culinary expectations should manage their expectations regarding food consistency.
Suitable for diners prioritizing ambiance and wine lists, though food consistency varies.
$$$sushi
Sushi
TripAdvisor review sample · 4.0/5 · 80 reviews
Osaki’s is renowned for traditional sushi, with many praising the freshness, authenticity, and attentive service in a cozy atmosphere. Some reviewers consider it superior to other local Japanese dining options. Conversely, negative feedback highlights issues with food freshness, slow or poor service, and pacing problems. The restaurant experiences polarized reviews, offering both highly acclaimed culinary experiences and significant disappointments regarding quality and hospitality.
Suitable for diners seeking authentic traditional sushi who are less concerned with cost.