City dining guide

Best restaurants in Arezzo

6 guide-listed restaurants — Michelin, Bib Gourmand, Black Pearl, Must-Eat List, World's 50 Best and more. Reference quality signals; never ranked by commission, no in-app checkout.

Michelin-starred 2

Octavin

★ Michelin€€€€Creative, Modern Cuisine

Housed in two small dining rooms connected by an arch on the ground floor of an old palazzo, this restaurant is decorated with materials that give it a minimalist feel – a combination of stone, wood and iron in the tables, glass in the mirrors and bottles on display, and paper in the books arranged in small niches, just like the lounge of a private home. There are just 20 seats in this warm, intimate and unfussy restaurant, as well as a large counter separated by an arch at the entrance which precedes the recently restructured kitchen. Observation of his own region has shown owner-chef Luca Fr

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.2/5 · 100 reviews

Octavin in Arezzo offers creative modern cuisine, praised for high-quality, intense flavors often inspired by stories or memories. Guests appreciate the attentive service and intimate atmosphere, though the space is extremely limited with only three tables. While many find the experience magical and unique, some negative reviews criticize the small portion sizes, poor value for money, and basic decor. The restaurant delivers a distinctive gastronomic journey, but those sensitive to portion sizes or seeking traditional comfort may find it lacking.

Suitable for diners seeking unique creative cuisine and an intimate setting, but less ideal for those prioritizing portion size and value.

Website

Il Falconiere

★ Michelin€€€€Tuscan, Contemporary

To get to this exclusive restaurant, you drive through an idyllic landscape of small lanes lined with dry-stone walls and fields belonging to the Baracchi farm estate, of which Il Falconiere and the magnificent hotel of the same name are a part. Many of the ingredients served here, such as wine and olive oil, are produced on the estate and the restaurant’s strong connection with its local landscapes is evident. Specialities such as Chianina beef, local garlic and pici pasta feature in dishes spiced with aromatic herbs and full of the strong flavours of Tuscany.

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.3/5 · 100 reviews

Il Falconiere offers contemporary Tuscan cuisine in Cortona with scenic hill views. Reviews highlight excellent food quality, particularly Chianina beef and creative dishes like anchovy ice cream, alongside generally impeccable service and a welcoming atmosphere. However, some guests report inconsistencies, including slow pacing, overcooked mains, or overly salty flavors. While many praise the Michelin-starred experience, others note limited menu choices and service lapses. The restaurant delivers a high-end dining experience, though individual satisfaction varies based on specific dish execution and service timing.

Suitable for diners seeking refined Tuscan cuisine and scenic views, with reasonable expectations for consistency.

Website

Bib Gourmand 1

Da Alighiero

Bib Gourmand€Tuscan

Nestled amid the cobbled streets of Anghiari, one of Italy’s most beautiful villages, this rustic-style restaurant is hidden behind a wooden door with glass panes and curtains. With its brick-vaulted ceiling, old cupboards, art on the walls and bottles everywhere, Da Alighiero has a warm, authentic ambience. The cuisine celebrates Tuscany’s classic favourites (don’t miss the tripe served in a spicy red sauce), while enthusiastic host Gianni is on hand with recommendations for the perfect wine.

TripAdvisor review sample · 3.5/5 · 80 reviews

Da Alighiero in Anghiari receives mixed reviews. Positive feedback highlights the charming historic atmosphere, personable service, and dishes like beef tartare, pistachio pesto pasta, and ricotta truffle pie. Conversely, negative reviews cite inconsistent food quality, including temperature issues, and opaque billing practices. While some praise the value, others criticize high wine and coffee prices, resulting in a polarized perception of affordability. The restaurant offers a distinct Tuscan experience but requires careful consideration regarding service consistency and cost transparency.

Suitable for diners seeking a unique historic atmosphere who verify pricing details beforehand.

Website

Other guide picks 3

Le Chiavi d'Oro

€€Modern Cuisine, Traditional Cuisine

Situated in Arezzo’s historic centre, this restaurant boasts an original, minimalist ambience with an elegant wood decor. The main focus here is on the cuisine, which is among the best not only in the city but also in the region. Skilful interpretations of traditional dishes, with a focus on Tuscany, where the gastronomic pleasure increases with each course.

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.5/5 · 80 reviews

Located in central Arezzo, Le Chiavi d'Oro offers modern and traditional cuisine. Reviews highlight high-quality ingredients, refined dishes like salmon and stuffed guinea fowl, and professional service. The ambiance is described as elegant and vintage. However, some guests report issues with meal pacing, seating errors, and inconsistent service efficiency. A few reviewers noted small portions and questioned the value for money, citing minor details like paper placemats. While generally praised for its harmonious atmosphere and culinary skill, experiences vary regarding operational smoothness.

Suitable for diners seeking refined cuisine and an elegant atmosphere, with advance booking confirmation advised.

Website

Osteria Grande

€€€Italian Contemporary, Seasonal Cuisine

This restaurant overlooking the magnificent Piazza Grande and the Loggia Vasariana that takes up one whole side of the square was opened in the summer of 2022 by the enthusiastic Fatjon and Lorenzo (if you ask, they’ll happily share their knowledge of Arezzo’s history with you). The former is at the helm in the kitchen where he expresses his passion for cuisine in seasonal, contemporary-style dishes such as pigeon breast, leg and fillet (each cut is prepared in the appropriate way) served with sweet onion and cocoa nibs, while the latter oversees the wine selection and recommends suitable pair

Website

Osteria del Borro

€€€Tuscan, Contemporary

In the heart of Valdarno, Osteria del Borro is located within a thousand-hectare estate that houses an authentic medieval village. In the summer, you can dine on a terrace with breathtaking views of the countryside, while in the winter, you can settle into an elegant room with soft tones and an open kitchen. There are three tasting menus, built around local products and, most importantly, the estate's own garden.

TripAdvisor review sample · 4.1/5 · 80 reviews

Osteria del Borro in San Giustino Valdarno offers contemporary Tuscan cuisine with an average rating of 4.1/5 from 80 reviews. Guests frequently praise the relaxing atmosphere, professional service, and high-quality food, noting the appealing open kitchen and central fireplace. However, negative feedback highlights inconsistencies in food freshness, inefficient service, and booking issues. While many describe the elegant setting and refined dishes as excellent, others report disappointing experiences regarding value and attentiveness. The restaurant generally provides a charming dining environment, though occasional lapses in service and food preparation may affect satisfaction.

Suitable for diners valuing ambiance and service quality; confirm reservations in advance.

Website