Poole's

Cuisine

American

Michelin

selected

Price

$$$

Website

https://ac-restaurants.com/pooles/

Description

First opened as Poole's Pie Shop in 1947 before switching to a diner, Poole's is the sort of restaurant that is part of the fabric of the community. The original horseshoe counters, recently restored, are available to book and also open for walk-ins. They also have a much larger dining space in a former warehouse next door.As for the food, Poole's promises good, honest cooking with a distinct nod to the South. Must-orders include tomato pie and North Carolina slow shrimp, and when they insist you try a side of their mac and cheese, listen to them.

Review score

4

Review count

80

Review summary

Poole's offers creative Southern cuisine in a modern diner setting with mixed reviews. Food quality is polarizing; mac & cheese, shrimp, and drinks are highly praised, while some mains are described as bland or unavailable due to poor supply planning. Service varies significantly: management is often considerate, but instances of slow pacing, long waits, and communication issues occur. The atmosphere is lively and nostalgic, though potentially challenging for those with hearing impairments. Value perceptions differ, with some finding it fair and others feeling overcharged for inconsistent experiences. Overall, it provides detailed, upscale comfort food but lacks consistent reliability in execution and service speed.

Best for

Suitable for diners seeking creative Southern cuisine who can tolerate service variability; verify dish availability in advance.

Restaurant facts are unified under a canonical restaurant ID; source ids are references. Commission never ranks. FlyerKey never transacts — any booking link is an off-site affiliate deep-link, and commission never influences ranking.