Old Vicarage

Cuisine

Modern Cuisine

Michelin

selected

Price

£££

Website

https://tessabramley.co.uk/restaurant/

Description

With a history dating back to 1846, this delightful stone-built former vicarage is situated in a semi-rural spot on the edge of the city. Two fixed-price menus – go for the 'Prestige' option if you want the full experience – offer ambitious, well-constructed dishes delivering assured flavours from high-quality ingredients. Roe deer from the Balmoral estate is a great example, providing a wonderful gamey flavour and cooked to a perfect tenderness. The grand-looking house is surrounded by mature grounds that are worth exploring.

Review score

4.8

Review count

80

Review summary

Located in Ridgeway near Sheffield, Old Vicarage offers modern fine dining with high ratings. Reviewers frequently praise the seasonal dishes, fresh ingredients, and excellent wine pairings. Service is generally described as warm and professional, though some note the traditional white-tablecloth style can feel overly formal or zealous. The ambiance is elegant, featuring a grand stone building and traditional decor. While most experiences are positive, a minority report issues with meal pacing, overly salty food, small portions, and poor communication regarding reservations or dietary needs.

Best for

Suitable for diners seeking high-quality seasonal cuisine and a traditional, elegant atmosphere.

Restaurant facts are unified under a canonical restaurant ID; source ids are references. Commission never ranks. FlyerKey never transacts — any booking link is an off-site affiliate deep-link, and commission never influences ranking.