FlyerKeyThe guest's hotel playbook
Search
Me
Publish
Search cities, hotels, brands…
1 / 24

Black Spur Inn

8.7/ 10Recommended
·Hotels
📍436 Maroondah HIghway · Narbethong ↗
Offsite parking discounted rates availableElectric bicycle charging stationFree beach shuttleAir conditioningBBQ facilitiesLuggage storageAll 83 facilities +
Review
04

Guest scores & sentiment

From 80 guest reviews · multi-source · as of 2026-07-20

Guests praised the forest setting, comfortable beds, friendly staff, and delicious food, noting good value. Complaints focused on aging facilities like slippery baths, minor cleaning oversights, odors, and occasional noise.

Dimension scores · cross-source

Service9.6
Location9.6
Cleanliness9.5
Rooms9.4
Surroundings9.2
Facilities9.0
Value8.8
Wi-Fi7.5
＋ PraisedGreat location & forest setting · Friendly & helpful staff · Excellent food & generous breakfast · Spacious, clean & comfortable rooms
－ ComplaintsOccasional musty or sewage odors · Minor cleaning oversights · Bath-shower area lacks grab rails · Some beds too firm or worn

KEYIdeal for those seeking nature and good dining. Be aware of older facilities; those with mobility issues should check bathroom safety.

FAQ · grounded in hotel data & reviews

locationHow is the hotel location? Is it far from Melbourne CBD?＋
Set in the forested Yarra Valley of Narbethong (Environment score 9.2), it is just a short drive to Melbourne CBD (Location score 9.6).
diningHow is the breakfast and dining experience?＋
The hotel offers a complimentary cooked breakfast, plus an on-site coffee shop and restaurant. Guests consistently praise the food across 80 reviews, with a Service score of 9.6.
coupleIs this hotel better for couples or families?＋
Marked as Adult Only but allows children with kid meals available. 47 couple travelers praised the spacious rooms and tranquil atmosphere, making it ideal for romantic getaways.
roomWhat are the room facilities and bed comfort like?＋
Rooms feature air conditioning, a minibar, free WiFi, flat-screen TV, and a private patio. Beds are highly rated (Rooms score 9.4), though some guests note aging fixtures.
policyWhat are the check-in and check-out times? Is express service available?＋
Check-in is at 14:00 and check-out at 10:00. Express and private check-in/check-out services are available, backed by a 9.6 Service score.
pros_consWhat are the most frequently mentioned pros and cons?＋
Pros include the forest setting, comfortable beds, great food, and good value. Cons focus on slippery baths, aging facilities, minor cleaning oversights, and occasional noise. Overall score is 9.1 from 80 reviews, with a 99% recommendation rate.
No checkout or paid ranking here — commission never drives content.
Book on FlyerTrip →