FlyerKeyThe guest's hotel playbook
Search
Me
Publish
Search cities, hotels, brands…
1 / 24

Vineyard Square Hotel & Suites

★★★★·8.8/ 10Recommended
·Hotels
📍38 North Water Street, Edgartown, Massachusetts, 02539 · Edgartown ↗
Free bicycles on site24-hour front deskGardenLuggage storageTerraceFree WiFiAll 17 facilities +
Review
04

Guest scores & sentiment

From 200 guest reviews · multi-source · as of 2026-07-17

Guests praise the prime Edgartown location, exceptional staff hospitality, and comfortable rooms. Common complaints include small room sizes, poor soundproofing/noise in the historic building, and occasional rudeness regarding pricing policies.

Dimension scores · cross-source

Location9.8
Cleanliness9.4
Service9.2
Value8.4
＋ PraisedPrime downtown location · Warm and attentive staff · Excellent breakfast selection · Charming common areas & free bikes
－ ComplaintsCompact room sizes · Older building & occasional noise · Some dated fixtures · High price vs. luxury expectations

KEYIdeal for those valuing location and service over space. Noise-sensitive guests should verify room conditions.

FAQ · grounded in hotel data & reviews

locationHow is the hotel's location? What attractions are nearby?＋
Located in the heart of Edgartown with a prime score of 9.8, it is within walking distance of Old Whaling Church and Edgartown Lighthouse.
serviceWhat is the quality of service like?＋
Staff service is highly praised with a dimension score of 9.2. Guests highlight the warm, professional hospitality and personalized care, such as anniversary surprises for couples.
diningAre there rich options for breakfast and dining?＋
Yes, breakfast is rated as abundant and delicious. The hotel features a restaurant and bar, offering guests convenient dining and relaxation options.
coupleIs this hotel suitable for couples?＋
Highly recommended for couples. 84 guest reviews praise the central location and personalized service, including anniversary surprises and high-quality breakfast.
familyIs it convenient for families with children? Any precautions?＋
Some suites suit families, but note there is no elevator, and the historic building may have noisy floors or plumbing issues. Parking is also limited.
roomHow are the room size and soundproofing?＋
This is a common drawback. Guests frequently report small room sizes and poor soundproofing due to the historic building structure, leading to potential noise disturbances.
No checkout or paid ranking here — commission never drives content.
Book on FlyerTrip →