FlyerKeyThe guest's hotel playbook
Search
Me
Publish
Search cities, hotels, brands…
1 / 24

Minnewaska Lodge

★★·8.9/ 10Recommended
·Lodges
📍3116 Route 44/55 · Gardiner ↗
Offsite parking discounted rates availableFitness facilities (surcharge)Air conditioningLuggage storageExpress check-in/check-outFacilities for disabled guestsAll 57 facilities +
Review
04

Guest scores & sentiment

From 80 guest reviews · multi-source · as of 2026-07-21

Guests praise the scenic mountain setting, friendly staff, and hiking access. Breakfast is generally liked but quality varies. Complaints focus on outdated facilities, potholed parking, noise issues, and occasional room defects like odors or broken appliances.

Dimension scores · cross-source

Wi-Fi10.0
Location9.6
Rooms9.4
Service9.4
Cleanliness9.2
Surroundings9.0
Facilities8.9
Value8.3
＋ PraisedExcellent location near hiking trails · Friendly and attentive staff · Generally well-received breakfast · Comfortable and clean rooms
－ ComplaintsHigh price or value concerns · Inconsistent breakfast quality and variety · Worn parking lot and distant spaces · Occasional room odors or equipment noise

KEYIdeal for nature lovers seeking a cozy vibe. Expect some wear-and-tear, avoid weekends for parking, and verify room views and amenities upon check-in.

FAQ · grounded in hotel data & reviews

locationHow is the location? Is it suitable for outdoor enthusiasts?＋
Located 8.7 km from Minnewaska State Park, it offers easy access to hiking and Mohonk Preserve. The location scores 9.6/10 for its stunning mountain views.
diningHow is the breakfast? Any tips?＋
Breakfast has good variety and dietary options but quality varies; some find it cheap or coffee average. A coffee shop is on-site.
coupleIs this hotel good for couples?＋
Highly recommended for couples. Guests praise thoughtful services like anniversary touches and the romantic cliff-view balconies.
familyAre pets allowed? Are there facilities for children?＋
Yes, pets are welcome and there are kids' outdoor play equipment. However, check for potential noise or odor issues in rooms.
roomAre the rooms outdated? What are the pros and cons?＋
Rooms score 9.4/10 with rustic charm and modern amenities. Cons include outdated fixtures, stained windows, missing outlets, and occasional odors or faults.
serviceHow is the staff service?＋
Staff service scores 9.4/10. Guests consistently praise the friendly, helpful, and attentive service provided by the team.
No checkout or paid ranking here — commission never drives content.
Book on FlyerTrip →