FlyerKeyThe guest's hotel playbook
Search
Me
Publish
Search cities, hotels, brands…
1 / 24

Gallows Point Resort

★★★★·9.4/ 10Excellent
·Hotels
📍3 AAA Gallows Point Road, P O Box 58, St. John, St John, 831 · St. John ↗
Proposal/romance packages availableExpress check-outFitness facilitiesHealth or beauty spa nearby24-hour front deskGardenAll 48 facilities +
Review
04

Guest scores & sentiment

From 266 guest reviews · multi-source · as of 2026-07-11

Guests praise stunning views, convenient location, and exceptional staff service, noting a condo-like comfort. Common complaints include outdated units, noisy metal roofs, tech issues, and hidden fees.

Dimension scores · cross-source

Location9.8
Rooms9.7
Surroundings9.6
Facilities9.5
Cleanliness9.2
Service9.1
Value8.4
＋ PraisedPrime location, walkable to Cruz Bay · Beautiful views · Friendly and helpful staff · Well-maintained grounds
－ ComplaintsSome rooms are dated · Noise issues · Unreliable hot water · Unreliable internet

KEYIdeal for those valuing views and walkability. Check unit condition, avoid noisy metal-roof rooms if sensitive, and note extra fees.

FAQ · grounded in hotel data & reviews

locationHow is the location? Is it convenient to go to town?＋
With a location score of 9.8, guests praise its seaside setting and easy walking access to Cruz Bay town.
diningDoes the hotel have a restaurant? What is special about it?＋
It features Ocean 362 for farm-to-table ocean views, plus well-equipped kitchens in rooms for self-catering.
coupleIs it suitable for couples? Any special services?＋
Highly rated by couples (131 reviews), offering proposal packages, beach yoga, and private dining with stunning sunset views.
familyAre children allowed? Are there any restrictions?＋
Children are allowed, but some families note strict bans for under-4s. Great for snorkeling, but watch out for noise.
roomHow are the room facilities? What are the pros and cons?＋
Rooms score 9.7 with condo-like comfort, but some report outdated furnishings, unstable hot water, and noisy metal roofs.
serviceHow is the staff service?＋
Service scores 9.1; guests praise enthusiastic staff and concierge, though isolated reports mention coldness or phone issues.
No checkout or paid ranking here — commission never drives content.
Book on FlyerTrip →