Catch at The Old Fishmarket
The upper floor of a striking, Grade-II-listed former fishmarket built from Portland stone is the setting for this characterfully rustic seafood restaurant. The tasting menu is based almost solely around fish and shellfish, with good use made of both high-end ingredients (native blue lobster) and less glamorous cuts elevated to impressive heights (skate jowl). In a heartening nod to the provenance of the produce, the name of the fishing boat and its skipper is noted next to each dish.
TripAdvisor review sample · 4.7/5 · 80 reviews
Located in Rodwell, Catch at The Old Fishmarket specializes in seafood and locally sourced, sustainable ingredients. Reviews frequently praise the high food quality and presentation, highlighting dishes like skate wing, oysters, and trout pastrami. The lunch tasting menu is particularly acclaimed. The atmosphere is described as relaxed and welcoming, with generally attentive service. However, punctuality is crucial as the entrance is locked and located upstairs. Negative feedback centers on inconsistent meal pacing, distant service, and concerns over value, with some guests finding prices high relative to portion sizes, particularly for wine pairings. While many consider it a top-tier dining experience, others find it pretentious or overpriced. It suits those prioritizing culinary provenance and innovation over cost-effectiveness.
Ideal for diners prioritizing ingredient provenance and culinary innovation; arrive exactly on time and manage price expectations.