I Sodi

Cuisine

Italian

Michelin

selected

Price

$$$

Website

https://www.isodinyc.com/

Description

Manhattan has no shortage of Italian restaurants, but surely Rita Sodi runs two of the most beloved ones. Just down the street from Via Carota, this cozy, buzzy hotspot remains a difficult reservation to score so consider planning on an early-hour walk-in. The kitchen watches the seasons closely in daily specials like grilled tomato and burrata, while also respecting that some signatures can never leave the menu. The perfectly layered lasagna is a must for first timers, and it contrasts wonderfully with a citrusy tangle of pappardelle al limon. Regardless of where you sit – bar, dining room, o

Review score

3.9

Review count

80

Review summary

Located in NYC's West Village, I Sodi holds a 3.9/5 average rating. Food highlights include the mole-high lasagna, fried artichokes, and delicate lemon pasta, though some guests found portions small or execution inconsistent. Service is polarizing; many praise the knowledgeable, warm staff, while others report rude attitudes, poor pacing, and unprofessionalism. The ambiance is simple and inviting, but reservations are hard to secure, often resulting in long waits or bar seating for walk-ins. Value varies by experience, with some finding it worth the effort and others feeling disappointed by the hospitality. Overall, it offers authentic Italian flavors but requires patience regarding service consistency and availability.

Best for

Suitable for diners willing to navigate booking challenges and service variability for authentic Italian cuisine.

Restaurant facts are unified under a canonical restaurant ID; source ids are references. Commission never ranks. FlyerKey never transacts — any booking link is an off-site affiliate deep-link, and commission never influences ranking.