FlyerKeyThe guest's hotel playbook
Search
Me
Publish
Search cities, hotels, brands…
1 / 24

The Menhaden Hotel

★★★★·9.4/ 10Excellent
·Hotels
📍207 Front Street · Greenport ↗
Offsite parking discounted rates availableAir conditioningFamily roomsLift / ElevatorLuggage storageExpress check-in/check-outAll 58 facilities +
Review
04

Guest scores & sentiment

From 279 guest reviews · multi-source · as of 2026-07-11

Guests praise exceptional staff service, clean rooms, and 24/7 floor pantries. Rooftop and location are highlights. Complaints focus on noise, lack of in-room tech, limited parking, and sparse bar selection.

Dimension scores · cross-source

Cleanliness9.8
Rooms9.6
Facilities9.6
Surroundings9.6
Service9.2
Location9.2
Wi-Fi9.0
Value9.0
＋ PraisedPrime location · Excellent staff service · Floor galleys with treats · Clean and comfortable rooms
－ ComplaintsNoise issues · Thermostat malfunctions · Limited breakfast options · Street noise/poor soundproofing

KEYIdeal for service-focused travelers. Avoid street-facing rooms if sensitive to noise. Drivers should verify parking.

FAQ · grounded in hotel data & reviews

locationHow is the location and transportation convenience?＋
Located in Greenport, it is within walking distance to town and the ferry. It is 41km from Splish Splash and 76km from the airport. Guests praise its prime location.
serviceWhat is the quality of service?＋
Service scores 9.2/10. Guests highly praise attentive staff like Mario and John. 24-hour front desk, concierge, and express check-in/out are available.
roomWhat are the highlights and drawbacks of the rooms?＋
Rooms score 9.6/10 for cleanliness and comfort, featuring AC, free WiFi, and flat-screen TVs. Unique floor pantries offer snacks. However, some lack charging ports/phones and have noise or rug hazards.
diningDoes the hotel offer breakfast or dining services?＋
The hotel has a coffee shop, bar, and offers packed lunches and room service. The rooftop lounge is popular. However, breakfast options are limited, and the bar menu is sparse.
familyIs this hotel suitable for families?＋
The hotel allows pets, has family rooms, and welcomes children. Floor pantries and the rooftop are great for families. Note: Some guests reported disputes over extra bed fees and limited parking.
coupleWhat experiences are recommended for couples?＋
Popular among couples, the hotel offers a prime location, spacious rooms, and a beautiful rooftop lounge. Attentive service creates a romantic atmosphere. Avoid street-facing rooms for less noise.
No checkout or paid ranking here — commission never drives content.
Book on FlyerTrip →