Search cities, hotels, brands…
1 / 24

The Cay

★★★★·8.5/ 10Recommended
·Hotels
Concierge serviceFence around poolElevatorPool sun loungersPool umbrellasSmoke-free propertyAll 9 facilities +
Review
04

Guest scores & sentiment

From 75 guest reviews · multi-source · as of 2026-07-22

Guests praise the unique island location, beach, and friendly staff. Major complaints include outdated facilities, non-functional pool, cold showers, and renovation noise.

Dimension scores · cross-source

Location9.2
Wi-Fi9.0
Service8.1
Rooms7.6
Cleanliness7.5
Value7.4
Facilities6.6
PraisedUnique island location and direct beach access · Friendly and accommodating staff · Quiet and private atmosphere · Fun water taxi experience
ComplaintsDated facilities and ongoing renovations · Pool and water features non-functional · Unreliable hot water and cold showers · Frequent room equipment failures

KEYSuitable for those seeking privacy and value. Expect aging facilities, potential hot water issues, and renovation noise.

No checkout or paid ranking here — commission never drives content.
Book on FlyerTrip →