Search cities, hotels, brands…
1 / 24

Montauk Yacht Club

★★★★·9.4/ 10Excellent
·Resorts
Check-in 04:00 PM / out 11:00 AM
Electric bicycle charging stationFitness facilities (surcharge)Health or beauty spa nearbyAir conditioningSwimming poolFamily roomsAll 75 facilities +
Review
Official

Spend the day on the private beach or dip into one of the 2 outdoor swimming pools. This hotel also features complimentary wireless internet access, concierge services, and gift shops/newsstands. Grab a bite at one of the hotel's 2 restaurants, or stay in and take advantage of the room service (during limited hours). Unwind at the end of the day with a drink at the bar/lounge or the poolside bar. Cooked-to-order breakfasts are available daily from 8:30 AM to 10:00 AM for a fee. Featured amenities include limo/town car service, a 24-hour front desk, and multilingual staff. Planning an event in Montauk? This hotel has 2100 square feet (195 square meters) of space consisting of conference space and 5 meeting rooms. Free self parking is available onsite. Make yourself at home in one of the 107 guestrooms featuring refrigerators and LCD televisions. Your bed comes with down comforters and premium bedding.

04

Guest scores & sentiment

From 204 guest reviews · multi-source · as of 2026-07-17

Guests praise the renovated elegance, waterfront location, and attentive service, highlighting complimentary activities and dining. Common complaints include poor soundproofing, AC noise, undisclosed fees, and limited off-season amenities.

Dimension scores · cross-source

Location9.7
Cleanliness9.1
Value9.0
Service8.9
Facilities8.7
Surroundings8.4
+ PraisedRenovated & upgraded · Excellent staff service · Beautiful views & peaceful · Great family facilities
- ComplaintsHigh/unclear extra fees · Peak season pricing · Thin walls/noise · Limited off-season ops

KEYIdeal for vacationers seeking luxury and service. Verify room views, noise sensitivity, and extra fees like pet/water club charges beforehand.

FAQ · grounded in hotel data & reviews

locationHow is the hotel's location and transportation access?+
Located on Star Island in Lake Montauk, the hotel enjoys a prime waterfront setting with a location score of 9.7. It sits near beaches and marinas, offering a tranquil yet convenient stay.
diningWhat dining options are available, and how is the quality?+
The property features Showfish, The Pool Club, and Il Forno, specializing in fresh seafood and Italian cuisine. Dining quality is consistently highlighted as a top guest positive.
coupleIs this hotel suitable for couples?+
Highly recommended. 78 couples praised the renovated elegance and lake views. Traveling off-peak is advised to avoid crowds and confirm seasonal facility availability.
familyWhat should families with children know before booking?+
The hotel welcomes children, with 74 families appreciating the safe water activities and spacious rooms. Note that soundproofing varies, and pool areas may get crowded during peak seasons.
policyWhat are the check-in/out times and pet policies?+
Check-in is at 16:00 and check-out at 11:00. Pets are welcome with provided bowls and baskets, alongside non-smoking rooms and luggage storage for added convenience.
facilityWhat recreational and fitness facilities does the hotel offer?+
The resort offers three pools, a private beach, and boat rentals, with a nearby health spa. Guests can also enjoy outdoor sports like tennis, volleyball, and horseshoes.
No checkout or paid ranking here — commission never drives content.
Book on FlyerTrip →