Search cities, hotels, brands…
1 / 24

The Scholar

★★★★·9.3/ 10Excellent
·Hotels
Check-in 03:00 PM / out 11:00 AM
Offsite parking discounted rates availableElectric bicycle charging stationFamily roomsLift / ElevatorLuggage storageSafety deposit boxAll 40 facilities +
Review
Overview · AI

The Scholar is a four-star hotel in Edinburgh, offering a quiet retreat near a park. While slightly removed from the city center, it provides easy access via transport links. Guests frequently praise the spacious rooms, comfortable beds, and professional, warm staff service. The breakfast selection is highlighted as rich and delicious. However, some visitors note issues with soundproofing, a flawed shower design, and the lack of air conditioning. Despite these drawbacks, the tranquil environment and high-quality dining make it suitable for travelers seeking comfort and peace. It is an ideal choice for those who prioritize sleep quality and attentive service over immediate proximity to downtown attractions.

04

Guest scores & sentiment

From 519 guest reviews · multi-source · as of 2026-07-05

Guests praise the exceptional staff service, comfortable rooms, and good breakfast. Common complaints include the location requiring transit/walking to the center, thin walls causing noise issues, showers lacking doors, plain exterior, and lack of air conditioning.

Dimension scores · cross-source

Cleanliness9.6
Surroundings9.4
Facilities9.3
Service8.4
Value8.0
Location8.0
Rooms4.0
+ PraisedSpacious and comfortable rooms · Friendly and helpful staff · Quiet and scenic environment · High-quality breakfast
- ComplaintsNo air conditioning/poor temperature control · Noise issues in some rooms · Crowded breakfast area · Limited parking availability

KEYIdeal for those valuing service and quiet campus vibes. Check parking rules, avoid noisy rooms if sensitive, and prepare for no AC.

FAQ · grounded in hotel data & reviews

locationHow is the location? Is it convenient to get to the city center?+
Located near Holyrood Park with a quiet environment (score 9.4). However, it is not within walking distance to the city center; public transport or a walk is required.
diningHow is the breakfast and dining?+
Breakfast is highly praised for its variety and local Scottish ingredients. The hotel features a restaurant, bar, and garden dining area for lunch and dinner, though some families noted food temperature could be improved.
roomAre the rooms comfortable? What are the pros and cons?+
Rooms are spacious, clean, and feature Elite mattresses (cleanliness score 9.6). Cons include poor soundproofing in some rooms, showers without doors, and a lack of air conditioning.
serviceHow is the staff service?+
Staff service is a major highlight, scoring 8.4. Guests consistently praise the team for being enthusiastic, professional, and helpful throughout their stay.
facilityWhat are the main facilities available?+
Facilities score 9.3, offering free Wi-Fi, on-site parking with EV charging, a Japanese garden, and golf access. Rooms include coffee makers and award-winning Novus tea.
policyWhat are the check-in/out times? Are pets allowed?+
Check-in is at 15:00 and check-out at 11:00. Pets are welcome with provided bowls and baskets. Cashless payment and contactless check-in/out are available.
No checkout or paid ranking here — commission never drives content.
Book on FlyerTrip →