Search cities, hotels, brands…
1 / 24

Travelodge by Wyndham Bay Shore Long Island

★★·7.2/ 10Good
TTravelodge by Wyndham·Wyndham Rewards·Motels
41 rooms· Check-in 02:00 PM / out 11:00 AM
24-hour front deskFree WiFiNo elevator (single level property)Parking (limited spaces)RV, bus, truck parking24-hour business centerAll 9 facilities +
Review
Official

Experience an abundance of unparalleled facilities and features at Travelodge by Wyndham Bay Shore Long Island. Maintain seamless communication using the complimentary Wi-Fi at hotel. For visitors traveling by automobile, complimentary parking is available. Craving relaxation? Make the most of your stay at the Travelodge by Wyndham Bay Shore Long Island with convenient amenities like room service and daily housekeeping at your disposal. Kindly note that smoking is prohibited in the hotel to ensure fresher air for all visitors. For visitors wishing to smoke, designated smoking zones can be found. At Travelodge by Wyndham Bay Shore Long Island, every guestroom is provided with convenient amenities and fittings to ensure a comfortable stay. Elevate your experience at hotel with the knowledge that certain rooms are equipped with linen service, ensuring a more pleasant stay for you. Certain rooms offer in-room amusement features such as the television for your enjoyment. In select rooms at the hotel, a refrigerator is available for those moments when it seems necessary. Essential restroom facilities are equally significant, and at the hotel, some visitor bathrooms offer a hair dryer to enhance your experience. Begin your day with a scrumptious on-site breakfast available each morning at Travelodge by Wyndham Bay Shore Long Island. At the hotel, an assortment of easily accessible and delicious meal choices are available to satisfy your appetite whenever it strikes.

04

Guest scores & sentiment

From 85 guest reviews · multi-source · as of 2026-07-19

Guests report mixed experiences. Positives include cleanliness, friendly manager Nick, and convenient location. Negatives involve strong odors, pests, outdated facilities, uncomfortable beds, poor breakfast, and inconsistent staff service.

Dimension scores · cross-source

Location7.0
Service5.9
Cleanliness5.4
Surroundings5.4
Facilities5.2
Value4.9
PraisedConvenient location · Good value · Friendly staff
ComplaintsPoor cleanliness · Bad odors · Outdated facilities · Poor breakfast

KEYSuitable for budget travelers needing basic sleep. Check for odors/pests; expect dated facilities and poor breakfast.

FAQ · grounded in hotel data & reviews

locationIs the hotel conveniently located? What is nearby?
The location scores 7.0 and guests praise its proximity to a shopping center, Gilgo State Park, and Great South Bay within a mile.
diningHow is the breakfast and are there dining options?
Breakfast receives negative feedback, though coffee, tea, and room service are available on-site.
familyIs this hotel suitable for family trips?
Children are welcome, and family reviewers highlight convenience and value, though some note hygiene and pet policy concerns.
roomWhat are the room facilities and comfort like?
Rooms feature AC, fridges, flat-screen TVs, free Wi-Fi, and rainfall showers, but facilities are dated and comfort varies.
serviceIs the front desk service friendly?
Service scores 5.9; while Manager Nick is frequently praised, front desk responsiveness and attitude are often criticized.
memberWhat are the Wyndham Rewards perks at this hotel?
Official benefits include bonus points for Diamond/Gold/Platinum members, while early check-in and late checkout are subject to availability.
No checkout or paid ranking here — commission never drives content.
Book on FlyerTrip →